Home > Shi'ism > Shi’i Objections

Shi’i Objections


Let us now look at a Shi`i objection. It is said that the names of the first three khulafa are not mentioned in the ayah, therefore denial of their virtue does not amount to rejection of the ayah. In response to this objection we refer to the testimony of Imam Baqir (posted above) wherein he includes the three khulafa in the purview of those whom the Qur’an praises and gives glad tidings.

This narration proves that according to Imam Baqir the three khulafa definitely fall within the scope of the ayah. The promise of Paradise which Allah here makes to the Muhajirin and the Ansar applies to them as well. It also confirms that the Imam was extremely upset at those who speak ill of the khulafa and regarded them as being outside Islam and Iman. There can thus be no answer except to say that it was all said in taqiyyah. But for how long can taqiyyah be invoked to explain things away? It is sad indeed that when Allah Himself makes such clear mention of the virtue of the Sahabah, and the Imams too mention it in terms no less lucid, that the Shi’ah are still looking for proof of their merit.


Another illusion of Shi’ah goes that by “Muhajirin” Allah means exclusively those who made hijrah sincerely for His sake, while by “Ansar” only those are meant who extended help solely for His pleasure. Those who emigrated or gave assistance for worldly reasons are therefore excluded. To this we respond in three ways.

Firstly, at the time when the Muhajirin emigrated from Makkah and the Ansar received them in Madinah, what worldly benefit was there to be gained? Did those who left Makkah hear that a treasure had been discovered in Madinah that they rushed to gain their share of it? Or did the Muhajirin bring such alot of wealth with them that the Ansar was tempted by it to take them into their own homes? If the hijrah of the Muhajirin and the nusrah of the Ansar were not for the sake of Allah, what was then the cause behind it?

Secondly, if it is true that the Muhajirin and the Ansar were motivated by worldly aims, then it must also follow (Allah forbid) that their praise as contained in the Qur’an must be meaningless and obsolete. If the hijrah of the Muhajirin and the nusrah of the Ansar were not for the sake of Allah, then about who is it that Allah says:

And the early pioneers – the Muhajirin and the Ansar

If they were all hypocrites, then about who is it that Allah says:

Allah is pleased with them, and they are pleased with him.

And if it is argued that some of them were sincere while others were motivated by worldly desires, we might well ask them to name the sincere ones who made hijrah and nusrah purely for the sake of Allah. The moment it comes down to giving names they will be unable to go beyond three or four. It is quite obvious that the hijrah and nusrah of such a small group does not achieve much.

Thirdly, this illusion has been refuted by Allah Himself in the Qur’an. He Himself undertook to answer for the Muhajirin and the Ansar. There are two other verses in the Qur’an wherein Allah has made it clear that the deeds of the Muhajirin and the Ansar were done for His sake. The first of the two is in Surah Hajj where Allah says about the Muhajirin:

‘those who were taken from their homes unjustly, for no reason other than that they said.- Allah is our Lord. (al-Hajj:40)

This ayah clearly proves that the cause for the emigration of the Muhajirin was nothing other than the fact that the unbelievers could not reconcile themselves to these people calling Allah their Lord, and as a result started persecuting them. If the Shi’ah will now, after hearing this ayah, still insist that the Muhajirin emigrated for worldly greed, then well and good. I will never ever say something like that.

About the Ansar, Allah Ta’ala says:

‘And those who, before them, who had settled into this abode (Madinah) and into Imaan, who love those who migrate to them, and have no jealousy in their breasts for that whic they (muhajirin) have been given, and give (the Muhajirin) preference over themselves even though they themselves were in need. And whoever is freed from his own covetousness, such are the successful?’ (al-Hashr 9)

Look at this ayah, and see how Allah praises the great-heartedness of the Ansar. Look how Allah Himself attests to the fact that when they received the Muhajirin in their midst and extended the hand of assistance to them, it was only for His sake.

It is confusing, to say the least, that while Allah Ta’ala openly declares that the hijrah of the Muhajirin and the nusrah of the Ansar were both sincerely done for His sake, that the Shi’ah could still insist it was for worldly greed. Friends, please ask yourself that when you do so, do you thereby show that you believe in the Word of Allah or that you reject it? Do you submit to the decree of Allah or do you oppose it? Allah says they were good; you say no, they were worse than bad. Allah says He is pleased with them and they are pleased with Him; you say no, it is all wrong, neither is Allah pleased with them nor are they pleased with Him. Allah says they made hijrah and nusrah solely for His sake; you say no, they did it out of worldly greed. Please think what you are saying and doing.

Brothers, had there been only one or two verses of this nature in the Qur’an there might have been scope to interpret it differently. But when the whole Qur’an is filled with references to the Muhajirin and the Ansar, then how is one to go about interpreting things away, and how far can one then make the claim that the meaning of the text has been corrupted? The real situation is that they have chosen the madhhab of `Abdullah ibn Saba, but now they are in a fix. They cannot refute the Qur’an, but neither are they accepting it.

Categories: Shi'ism
  1. No comments yet.
  1. January 22, 2011 at 7:23 pm

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: